Jim, here is a little maybe unknown info on the token you seek. There are actually two varieties of the Central City Token. In all of my years of collecting I have seen only three of the shinny area between the antlers. Almost all are frosted between the antlers. My first one I owned I sold maybe 13 years ago with my Colorado Collection. I needed money to buy a new table saw for work. No regrets I still have that saw and use it often. Then I started collecting Colorado again about 10 years ago. Since then I have seen only two more with the shinny area between the antlers. Quite a few or most are frosted between the antlers on the Central City token. All of the others in the set I have only found them with shinny between the antlers. The reverses are the same on both tokens.
Common with frosted between Antlers
I would say Rare with Shinny between the Antlers